Fair Judging – What to Expect
The fair is a great opportunity for youth to get feedback and evaluation on the projects on which they have chosen to work during the year. This experience can be both motivating and educational for 4-Hers. Critiques from judges can serve as a guide to further improvement. The judging process is probably more valuable than the award or recognition. To plan, practice, and present a finished product is to “learn by doing.”
Types of Fair Judging
What is Face-to-Face judging? Face-to-face judging of certain fair projects is performed to help exhibitors learn the strengths and weaknesses of their project directly from the judge. Exhibitors report to the judge with their projects at the designated time. They meet face-to-face with the judge, who learns more about the work the exhibitor put into the entry while the judge evaluates it. Exhibitors then receive a ribbon for the quality of the exhibit & knowledge of their project, as well as new information they can use to do better next year.
What is Danish judging? The Danish system of judging provides more exhibitors a chance to receive a ribbon for their entries. Instead of placing only the best four exhibits and giving them a blue, red, white, or pink ribbon (like in Open Class) all entries are placed. All entries receive a premium and ribbon. The number of blue, red, white, and pink ribbons a judge hands out depends on the number of entries in the class. For example, if there are 8 entries in a class, up to 2 can receive a blue rating, up to 4 red ratings, up to 6 white ratings, and up to 8 pink ratings.
What is Conference Judging? Conference judging is a combination of face-to-face and Danish judging. In conference style judging, the exhibitors and exhibits come before the judge by Class. The judge may ask youth questions about their project and use the knowledge as well as the quality of the exhibit to place the entries according to the Danish method of placing.
Blue Ribbon Youth It is important to recognize that judging is a personal opinion and that evaluation will vary among judges. Graciously accepting constructive criticism of one’s work is a life skill. Let’s strive to recognize that 4-H YOUTH are more important than 4-H projects. A blue ribbon 4-H member with a red ribbon chicken is more desirable than a red ribbon member with a blue ribbon chicken!
Some Things to keep in mind…about Judges and the Judging Process
If you’ve done your best work on your project, it’s disappointing not to get the rating you were expecting. Just remember – the judge’s opinion is simply one person’s opinion. A different judge might have given you a different placing. But even if you don’t agree with the judge, it’s worth paying attention to what he or she has to say about your project. You could get some great ideas for how to do even better next time.
Here are some tips about feedback:
- Pay attention to what the judge liked instead of getting upset about what he or she didn’t like. Even if there were some negative comments, there were probably just as many positive ones!
- Don’t be nervous about face-to-face judging. The judge is truly interested in youth, otherwise he or she wouldn’t be there. Relax so you can be your friendly, natural self when the judge meets with you. And if you don’t understand something he or she says, be sure to say so.
- Think about how you can use the judge’s feedback. What can you do differently if you intend to keep working on this kind of project? What will you want to do the same way?
What if you were the judge? What kind of rating would you give your project if you were judging it? Be honest!
Your opinion matters. Being able to have fun and learn how to do something worthwhile is just as important as whatever the judge thought about your work.
|Shawano County 4H Program is on Facebook!|
If you have any questions regarding 4-H Positive Youth Development in Shawano County, please contact:
|Megan Suehring, 4-H Positive Youth Development Educator Shawano County Courthouse 311 North Main Street, Room 109 Shawano, WI 54166-2198 Phone: 715-526-4869 Fax: 715-526-4875 Email: firstname.lastname@example.org|
|Terri Brunner, 4-H & Extension Coordinator Shawano County Courthouse 311 N Main Street, Room 109 Shawano, WI 54166-2198 Phone: 715-526-6136 Fax: 715-526-4875 Email: email@example.com|
|Tami Goers, Office Assistant Shawano County Courthouse 311 N Main Street, Room 109 Shawano, WI 54166-2198 Phone: 715-526-6136 Fax: 715-526-4875 Email: firstname.lastname@example.org|